TOP
(Sumana Harihareswara / Creative Commons)

Media Workers of the World Unite

Co-published by the Economic Hardship Reporting Project and Dissent Magazine.

 

The most exciting trend in American online media is collective ownership. In a wave of new media cooperatives, the same journalists and editors who are drafting, filing, and publishing articles are also in charge of balancing budgets, hiring new staffers, and deciding who, if anyone, gets to advertise on their websites. In stark contrast to Vox, Bustle, Buzzfeed, and other layoff-plagued ventures, these cooperatives feel like they’re genuinely built to last.

 

Many media cooperatives have debuted since the former staffers at Deadspin, the popular 2010s-era sports blog, collectively launched Defector in 2020. Discourse Blog was launched the same year by writers and editors from the shuttered progressive news site Splinter, and the media cooperative landscape now includes 404 Media, Aftermath, Hearing Things, and a multitude of others. But Defector has become the paragon, demonstrating a template for shared ownership and control that seasoned media professionals have sought to replicate. Co-ops work well when their members already work well together. That might sound like a catch-22, but the graveyard of beloved online publications is full of newsrooms that satisfy this precondition. Being a media co-op often means taking the camaraderie that existed at one publication and legally enshrining it in another. As Defector’s Kelsey McKinney and Discourse Blog’s Aleksander Chan wrote in the Nation, “When you know everyone’s deal, it can be easier to reach consensus on difficult decisions.”

 

One benefit of workplace democracy and self-determination infusing online media is that reading on the internet feels fun again, recalling the glory days of Gawker or Vice. It’s like traveling back in time to a lost era, before private equity hijacked digital publications and Big Tech siphoned off their ad revenue, when journalists were paid for their fearlessness. Much of this involved pulling back the curtain separating newsroom and audience. In its “Behind the Blog” series, 404 Media openly discusses the labor that goes into its features and investigative reports on the tech industry. Once a year, video-game news site Aftermath runs “Inside Baseball Week,” where it publishes journalism all about the state of video game journalism, including about Aftermath itself.

 

But peeking behind the curtain also reveals journalism’s hard truths. Much of the broader terrain hasn’t changed—i.e., media outlets are still getting bought up and turned into content slop buckets. There are some newer concerning developments, though, like the traffic apocalypse and subscription fatigue. Google now buries search results underneath AI-generated summaries, and Elon Musk has been accused of shadow banning media outlets on X. Both have throttled reader traffic to publications that rely on these channels—even institutions as seemingly invulnerable as the New York Times and Washington Post. Meanwhile, Substackers who found success at the start of this decade have seen their monthly revenues plummet. Though there isn’t a definitive explanation, it’s likely that cost-of-living concerns are pushing readers to cut out spending that feels extraneous—especially paid subscriptions.

 

By nature of their shared ownership and control, co-ops are better suited than conventional startup publications to absorb these blows. Still, their current financing strategy can only take them so far. Subscriptions mostly benefit teams of writers and editors with pre-established audiences willing to throw down money for them. Lesser-known journalists who want to launch their own publications lack the means to capitalize on this formula because they don’t already have avid readers. As a result, we may see the surge in co-ops die down, as there are now fewer teams of former colleagues able to collectivize their clout in this way.

 

Due to the vagaries of subscription revenue, many co-owners can only afford to pay themselves part-time; those who are full-time run a greater risk of burnout. As one staffer from Aftermath told Nieman Lab, “One of the challenges of this space is that you have this vision of your perfect job: Finally, you’re out of the thumb of the traffic-obsessed boss. . . . But the reality is that now you have all these other jobs that [other] people used to do, and now you have to do them too.”

 

For media co-ops, keeping tabs on subscription metrics is both necessary and a source of deep anxiety. How many readers are still paying? How many subscriptions have ended? How will they impact the year to come? Is it still realistic for there to even be a year to come?

 

***


In an essay on the uncertain future of funding for American journalism in
Defector, Diana Moskovitz writes that “We will not subscribe our way out of this dire crisis of our democracy.” It’s hard not to read this line as somewhat self-referential—after all, Defector earns the majority of its revenue through reader subscriptions. The funding model keeping this and most other cooperative sites afloat prioritizes self-preservation, but it’s no substitute for much-needed transformative policy. The title of Moskovitz’s essay spells out what’s required: “We Need A New Deal To Save Local Journalism.” Given their collective success in proving that a better media industry is possible, media co-ops are well positioned to lead the charge. What should be their strategy?

 

A worthwhile goal might be launching a federation. This structure could allow co-ops to come together, roadmap such a New Deal–style agenda, and hold each other accountable to it. Crucially, it could give readers—who have been equally responsible for making these democratic alternatives viable—the chance to participate at every step, formalizing the openness that already exists between newsrooms and their audiences. This is preferable to individual publications giving voting power to their paying readerships. It would be grueling for small teams to invest time and energy into such drastic ownership expansions, plus it wouldn’t necessarily lead to a unified front across the sector.

 

A federation of American media co-ops would find itself in great company. The U.S. Federation of Worker Cooperatives (USFWC) is a leading force in the solidarity economy, with a membership totaling over 400 organizations, including worker-owned publications like Hell Gate and the 51st. The federation was responsible for developing the National Worker Cooperative Development and Support Act, introduced by Representative Ro Khanna, which seeks to remove regulations and barriers to worker co-op development nationwide. The USFWC also publishes research reports through its Democracy at Work Institute and offers valuable member services, like training seminars and health benefit programs.

 

Just north of the border is the journalism coalition Unrigged, which doubles as a news aggregator. Canada passed legislation in 2023 forcing social media platforms to compensate news outlets for disseminating their articles, but to avoid paying fees, Meta blocked all links to articles on Facebook and Instagram for users based in Canada. In response, independent media outlets from across the country formed Unrigged. Publications that share their work on Unrigged agree to regularly promote the platform to their readers and pay annual dues. Among its members are a number of co-ops, such as New Feeling, Pivot, the NB Media Co-op, and Antler River Media.

 

A precursor to both Unrigged and the USFWC was the Indymedia movement. In 1999, hacktivists and citizen journalists in Seattle created the Independent Media Center (IMC), which published on-the-ground coverage of protests against the World Trade Organization. Rather than leave it up to traditional outlets to steer the narrative, they sought to “be the media” themselves. Their innovative website was an open-publishing platform where anyone could write and post articles, reaching readers in an instant. The model went, for lack of a better word, viral, with different Indymedia collectives quickly sprouting up around the world. As Todd Wolfson writes in his 2014 book Digital Rebellion, “Much of this growth was completely decentralized, with no connection to the original founders of the Seattle IMC.”

 

Today, Indymedia is mostly dormant; a few collectives remain active to varying degrees. But there has yet to be a federated movement comparable in scale—in journalism or otherwise. Indymedia mainstreamed anti-neoliberal causes too often vilified by the corporate press, and its global network of listservs, chatrooms, and open-publishing tools was unparalleled. Yet despite the obvious political nature of the work it published, the movement itself didn’t have a clear-cut ideology. Wolfson notes that Indymedia’s charter “simply enshrine[d] the necessity of autonomous and democratic decision-making processes,” and the lack of detail made it difficult “to make proactive decisions or create coherent, shared plans.”

 

In their own federation, today’s media co-ops can aspire to what made Indymedia successful, namely its networked infrastructure, while avoiding that movement’s shortcomings. These publications are in the habit of practicing workplace democracy, engaging with their subscribers, and uplifting each other (blogs that podcast together stay together). For these reasons, they would have a much easier time drafting a comprehensive charter that favors workers and readers alike. Media co-ops should be empowered to advance a bold vision for democratic, publicly funded media and simultaneously demonstrate what that vision could look like in practice.

***

For now, let’s call this new organization the American Media Federation. Publications that wish to join the AMF should be democratic workplaces—primarily cooperatives, but also independently owned and nonprofit outlets whose staff are unionized. No matter the workplace structure, employees must be able to vote on major decisions and/or for representatives to carry out such decisions. Each workplace’s set of bylaws ought to be easily accessible and rigorously upheld. Readers, in turn, could gain access to federated publications either through volunteer labor or through purchasing bulk subscriptions. Resources could also be pooled in other ways. Last year, for instance, Defector and Start.coop, a solidarity economy incubator, won a $1.5 million grant to develop the Shared Media Services Project, a hub of affordable back-office services like HR and accounting specifically geared toward independent media. An AMF could be the permanent home for such services.

 

What would a New Deal for journalism look like? One option is fighting to expand civic information consortiums, a glimmer of hope against the decades of neglect that public media has endured in this country. New Jersey directs taxpayer dollars toward independent media outlets in the state through a grantmaking nonprofit called the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium. Because of state law, the nonprofit has no degree of ownership or control over any of its grantees—shielding it from attempts to paint it as a ploy to produce state-run media. However, it consistently receives meager funding from the state, with next year’s allocation slated to be only $1 million, one of its lowest amounts yet. As various states are in the process of developing their own consortiums, this level of funding must not become the norm.

 

An AMF could push New Jersey and other states to increase their consortium budgets. It could also advocate for citizen voices to have a predominant stake in these models. Political economists have already drafted up ideas in this vein. Robert W. McChesney and John Nichols have proposed a Local Journalism Initiative, wherein the federal government would give funds to municipalities across the country, and citizens would vote on allocating those federal dollars to local news outlets—similar to public matching funds programs for political campaigns. Victor Pickard builds on their proposal with Public Media Centers, hubs for noncommercial media governed by their local readers and writers. These ideas should inform the AMF’s political agenda because they emphasize direct democracy, countering the sense that state-subsidized journalism would presage centralized state-run media.

 

These considerations factor into the greater political context beyond the midterm elections. If the Democrats are serious about winning the presidency, restoring funding to PBS and NPR won’t be enough. What good would that do, when the United States was already one of the lowest-spending countries on public media before Trump’s re-election? The anti-establishment fervor of recent primary elections has shown that the tepid centrism of restoring norms no longer holds sway. Bigger proposals captivate the electorate. There’s actually a chance that media co-ops, if they’re mobilized enough, could influence the platforms of presidential and congressional hopefuls. For instance, the AMF could make endorsements on the condition that candidates back a civic information consortium at the federal level.

 

Part of what made online media companies so popular in the 2010s was that they had nothing to hide from their readers. Sure, there was the clickbait and smut, but there was also the tendency of blogs to make journalism out of themselves. You could find Hamilton Nolan openly telling Gawker’s readers that staffers were planning to unionize, or Laura Wagner investigating the downfall of Deadspin in its very pages. This decade, we’ve seen many of these same media professionals channel this transparency into solidarity. But cooperative publications are well positioned to go even farther and continue to change the industry for the better. With a federation, they have the opportunity to keep their momentum going by making their readers part of the story. More than pulling back the curtain, now might be the time to tear it down entirely.

Author

  • Eli Zeger

    Eli Zeger is a writer, editor, and musician with work published in the Baffler, the Boston Review, Frieze, and other outlets. Eli is currently in the Media Studies MA at Concordia University, where he is researching media co-ops.

Save An Endangered Species: Journalists

Eli Zeger is a writer, editor, and musician with work published in the Baffler, the Boston Review, Frieze, and other outlets. Eli is currently in the Media Studies MA at Concordia University, where he is researching media co-ops.

Skip to content