
The Return of Child Labor
Co-published by the Economic Hardship Reporting Project and the New York Review of Books.
For years I have been haunted by a grainy video I saw in 2023, when I was interviewing poultry processing workers in Green Forest, Arkansas. In those months I spoke often with the organizer Magaly Licolli, who directs Venceremos, a grassroots organization dedicated to protecting the rights of poultry workers. One day we were sitting in her office in Springdale a few miles from the headquarters of Tyson Foods, the largest meat processing company in the US and, after the Brazilian firm JBS, the second largest in the world. After the subject turned to child labor, she pulled out her phone and showed me footage that another laborer had recorded of two migrant children, fourteen and fifteen years old, working as chicken catchers in a cavernous rural poultry house. The video was dark, but it was clear that they were using their bare hands to grab each chicken by the feet and hurl it into a nearby crate. Their bodies showed up only in outline, like ghostly shadows.
Earlier that year, Licolli told me, six chicken catchers—four adults and two children—had come to Venceremos’s office to seek help. The two minors were asleep when they arrived, she said, “because they hadn’t slept for so many hours.” The catchers explained that the contractor who hired them had denied them a week’s wages because—although they had worked fourteen-to-fifteen-hour days under physically extreme, sometimes dangerous conditions—they hadn’t managed to finish crating 56,000 chickens. According to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), the catching and cooping of poultry for transport or market is strictly prohibited for minors under the age of sixteen.
After some asking around, Licolli found the name of the contractor, called him, and told him he had to pay the chicken catchers. “Otherwise, I would have involved the Department of Labor,” she told me. The contractor agreed. Licolli drove to Decatur, some thirty miles from Springdale, to pick up the money, and “that’s how that was resolved.”
In the years that followed, I thought back to those teenagers often. Who was the contractor they worked for? How many other minors did that employer hire? How many other children were working dangerous fifteen-hour shifts? In its brevity and ambiguity, their story seemed to show the predicament of so many children laboring in the poultry processing industry and other dangerous jobs across the US. Working in informal arrangements, they have come to rely on advocates like Licolli to push for their rights, sometimes through similarly informal channels. Many of the children she met in Arkansas, she said, had arrived at the US–Mexico border as unaccompanied minors. The teenagers in this case, she explained, were K’iche, the largest Indigenous Maya ethnic group in Guatemala, and like most immigrant children in the industry, they had “come with a mind [to] making money to send…back to their very poor families.”
I met with Licolli during a historic nationwide spike in child labor violations. That fiscal year, according to The Washington Post, the US labor department “found 5,792 minors working in violation of child labor laws,” an increase of 49 percent from the previous year and “an 88 percent increase since 2019.” Pete Gess, the economic policy director of Arkansas Advocates for Children & Families, noted in a 2024 report that Arkansas’s Department of Labor and Licensing had identified a 266 percent increase in child labor violations from 2020 to 2023.
At the time I lived in downtown Little Rock, among sprawling, old, ruinous houses. Often I heard Spanish while walked down the street and looked up to see visibly underage immigrant children working on roofing crews. Sometimes I would shout up to ask them where they were from and wait for them to respond—“Guatemala” or “Mexico.” That same year Arkansas was one of eight states that made national headlines for systemic child labor violations: that February the Department of Labor found six children between the ages of thirteen and seventeen working the night shift for a third-party contractor called Packers Sanitation Services Inc. (PSSI) at a Tyson Foods plant in Green Forest, where they used harsh chemicals to clean blood, fat, bone, gristle, and skin from machines powerful enough to decapitate a worker.
Even as these violations proliferated, lawmakers in Republican-led states were taking aim at the regulations themselves. Between 2021 and 2023, fourteen states introduced or passed bills that weakened child labor laws. Two laws in particular, both passed in 2023, were at the forefront of this trend. One was in Iowa; the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), which monitors child-labor legislation, called it “one of the most dangerous rollbacks of child labor laws in the country” for, among other things, “allowing state agencies to waive restrictions on hazardous work for 16–17-year-olds in a long list of dangerous occupations.”
The other was in Arkansas. Less than a month after the Labor Department announced its findings about the Green Forest plant, Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders, who had served as Donald Trump’s press secretary during his first term, signed a bill called the Youth Hiring Act. By removing a century-old Division of Labor permission that required a parental signature for any child under sixteen seeking employment, the law effectively eliminated the only database that had kept track of working minors in the state. Sanders maintained that “all child labor laws will still apply and we expect businesses to comply just as they are required to do now.” But when I spoke to child advocates like the policy analysts Nina Mast and Reid Maki about the bill two years after it passed, both stressed that it had reduced state oversight at a time when child-labor violations were increasing.
Nationwide, the number of minors employed in violation of federal law remains at near-record highs. After falling to 4,030 in the 2024 fiscal year, the figure rose to 5,272 in 2025. Hazardous work violations, such as those the labor department has investigated in Arkansas’s meatpacking industry, have more than doubled since 2015, according to federal data. The state-level legislative push to dilute child-labor reporting and enforcement, meanwhile, has only gathered force. According to the EPI’s reporting, lawmakers in thirty-three states have by now introduced bills that weaken child labor laws. In 2023 Arkansas and Iowa were two of four states to successfully enact such legislation; now, three years later, fifteen states have done so. This wave of legislation may not directly affect the undocumented migrant children at the center of many recent high-profile child-labor investigations, who often take jobs via informal arrangements or under aliases, but it seems likely to discourage states from taking action to protect them and other vulnerable minors. Partly in response to these rollbacks, other legislatures have meanwhile strengthened their protections against child labor, from liberal strongholds like California and New York to red states like Texas and Alabama.
“When I started at the Wage and Hour Division in 2021,” Jessica Looman—who spent four years running the federal agency’s efforts to enforce labor laws across the country—told me in June 2025, “I did not think that by the end of 2022 our number one issue would be finding hundreds of children employed in the meatpacking industry in America.” Gess, at the Arkansas Advocates for Children & Families, stressed when we spoke in Little Rock that child labor “shouldn’t be a political issue.” In recent years, however, it has become precisely that. The rollback of child labor protections in Arkansas, I came to see, reflected a broader, increasingly politicized national campaign to weaken labor regulations, expand youth employment, and redefine the limits of hazardous and dangerous work for children.
Our current approach to regulating child labor dates back to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) of 1938, which barred minors under eighteen from hazardous occupations. In 1941 a Georgia company, Darby Lumber, challenged the law and arrived at the Supreme Court, arguing that the states, not Congress, should have the power to regulate employment conditions. The justices, however, unanimously upheld the FLSA.
Over the past several decades Republicans have made repeated attempts to roll back child labor legislation. In 1984 President Ronald Reagan addressed Congress to propose the Youth Employment Opportunity Wage Act. “Studies over the past decade,” he insisted, “have repeatedly demonstrated that the minimum wage has reduced job opportunities for large numbers of our youth.” But lawmakers and labor organizations warned that the act would leave workers more vulnerable to exploitation, and the bill failed. In 2011 the Republican presidential candidate Newt Gingrich called child labor laws “truly stupid” and proposed putting poor children to work sweeping the floors of their classrooms: “Most of these schools ought to get rid of the unionized janitors, have one master janitor and pay local students to take care of the school.”
